When your child has a fever, you want relief-fast and safe.
It’s 2 a.m. Your toddler is burning up, crying, and won’t settle. You grab the medicine cabinet, but now you’re stuck: acetaminophen or ibuprofen? Which one works better? Which is safer? And why does your pediatrician keep asking for your child’s weight instead of their age?
The truth is, both medications are commonly used, widely available, and generally safe when used correctly. But mixing them up, guessing doses, or using the wrong product can lead to serious harm. This isn’t about choosing between two pills-it’s about understanding how they work, when to use each, and how to avoid the most common mistakes parents make.
What’s the difference between acetaminophen and ibuprofen?
Acetaminophen (also called paracetamol) and ibuprofen are both fever reducers and pain relievers, but they work differently in the body.
Acetaminophen reduces fever and eases pain by acting on the brain’s temperature control center. It doesn’t fight inflammation. That’s why it’s often chosen for teething pain or mild headaches.
Ibuprofen, on the other hand, is an NSAID. It lowers fever and pain by blocking chemicals that cause inflammation. That makes it more effective for swelling, ear infections, or sore muscles. It also lasts longer-up to 8 hours versus 4-6 hours for acetaminophen.
Here’s what the data shows: In studies of children under two, ibuprofen brought down fevers faster and kept them down longer. One 2021 review of 85 studies found kids were 1.8 times more likely to be fever-free at four hours after taking ibuprofen than acetaminophen. That’s not a small difference-it’s the difference between a restless night and a few hours of sleep.
Age limits: When can you give each medicine?
Age matters more than you think.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says: Don’t give acetaminophen to babies under 3 months unless a doctor tells you to. Why? Their livers are still learning how to process medications. A small mistake in dosing can overload their system.
For ibuprofen, the cutoff is 6 months. Infants under that age have kidneys that aren’t fully developed. Ibuprofen can reduce blood flow to the kidneys, raising the risk of injury-especially if they’re dehydrated from fever or vomiting.
That doesn’t mean you’re stuck. If your 2-month-old has a fever, call your pediatrician. Don’t wait. Fevers in young babies can signal serious infections. Never guess. Never wing it.
Dosing: Weight, not age, is the key
Here’s the biggest mistake parents make: dosing by age.
According to a 2021 audit from a major children’s hospital, 68% of dosing errors in kids under two happened because caregivers used the age-based chart on the bottle instead of the child’s actual weight.
Acetaminophen: 7-15 mg per kilogram of body weight, every 4-6 hours. Max: 75 mg/kg per day.
Ibuprofen: 4-10 mg per kilogram, every 6-8 hours. Max: 40 mg/kg per day.
Example: A 10-pound baby weighs about 4.5 kg. That means:
- Acetaminophen: 32-68 mg per dose (about 1.25-2.5 mL of 160 mg/5 mL concentration)
- Ibuprofen: 18-45 mg per dose (about 0.75-1.875 mL of 50 mg/mL concentration)
Always use the syringe or dosing cup that comes with the medicine. Never use a kitchen spoon. Those are wildly inaccurate. And never use adult formulas. They’re five to ten times stronger. In 2022, 17% of pediatric poisoning cases came from accidental ingestion of adult pain relievers.
Safety: What are the real risks?
Both medicines are safe when used right. But both can hurt if used wrong.
Acetaminophen overdose is the leading cause of acute liver failure in children in the U.S. It doesn’t happen from one mistake-it happens from repeated small mistakes. Giving it every 4 hours for 3 days straight? Adding it to a cold medicine that already contains it? That’s how it happens.
One 2021 study found that 29% of acetaminophen-related liver injuries in kids under six came from combination cold and flu products. Always check the ingredient list. If it says “acetaminophen,” “APAP,” or “paracetamol,” you’re doubling up.
Ibuprofen’s biggest risk is kidney stress. It’s rare, but it can happen if the child is dehydrated, has the flu, or has been vomiting. Watch for signs: dry mouth, no wet diaper in 8 hours, lethargy. If you see those, stop the medicine and call your doctor.
There’s also emerging research about acetaminophen and asthma. A 2022 meta-analysis found kids exposed to acetaminophen in their first year had a 1.6 times higher risk of developing asthma by age 6. It’s not proof it causes asthma-but it’s enough to make some pediatricians think twice before reaching for it for every little fever.
Alternating or combining? Don’t do it without a plan.
You’ve probably heard: “Alternate acetaminophen and ibuprofen to keep the fever down.”
It sounds smart. But it’s risky.
A 2023 AAP study found alternating did bring down fever faster-but only if parents kept perfect records. In real life? 63% of parents who tried it ended up giving both meds too close together, or too much of one. That’s how overdoses happen.
Unless your doctor gives you a written schedule, don’t alternate. If one medicine isn’t working after 4-6 hours, wait. Try a sponge bath. Offer fluids. Call your pediatrician. Don’t reach for the second bottle.
What about brand names vs. generics?
Children’s Tylenol and Children’s Motrin are the big names. But generics are just as safe and cost 60-70% less.
The active ingredient is the same. The flavoring? Slightly different. The dosing device? Often better in generics because manufacturers learned from past mistakes.
In 2011, the FDA required all liquid acetaminophen for kids to be standardized to 160 mg per 5 mL. Before that, some bottles had 80 mg per 0.8 mL. Parents mixed them up. Kids got overdosed. The change cut dosing errors by 43%.
Today, both brand and generic products must include a calibrated dosing device. Always use it. Always check the concentration. Always write down the time and dose.
How to give medicine safely
- Use the syringe or cup that came with the bottle. Not a spoon. Not a medicine dropper.
- Hold your child upright. Never lay them flat when giving liquid medicine.
- Give the full dose. Don’t stop if they spit some out. If they vomit within 15 minutes, call your doctor before giving more.
- Keep medicines locked up. Kids can open bottles. One 2022 report found 32% of accidental ingestions happened in homes where medicine was left on counters.
- Write down each dose in a notebook or phone app. Include time, medicine, dose, and reason.
Many parents say they feel more confident after two or three visits to the pediatrician where they practiced dosing with a nurse. Don’t be afraid to ask for a demo. It’s part of the job.
When to call the doctor
Medicine helps. But it doesn’t fix the cause.
Call your pediatrician if:
- Your baby is under 3 months and has a fever of 100.4°F or higher
- Your child won’t drink, hasn’t peed in 8 hours, or is unusually sleepy
- The fever lasts more than 72 hours
- The fever goes away but comes back after 24 hours
- Your child has a rash, stiff neck, trouble breathing, or seizures
Fevers are the body’s way of fighting infection. The goal isn’t to get rid of the fever-it’s to make your child comfortable enough to rest and drink. If they’re playing, drinking, and responding to you, that’s a good sign-even if their temperature is still 102°F.
What’s changing in 2025?
The AAP is updating its fever guidelines in January 2025. They’re reviewing new data on acetaminophen and asthma, ibuprofen use in babies under 6 months, and long-term safety.
Right now, the evidence is clear: ibuprofen is more effective for fever. Acetaminophen is gentler on the stomach. But safety isn’t about which one is “better.” It’s about using the right one, at the right dose, at the right time.
As one pediatric pharmacist put it: “The medicine isn’t dangerous. The mistake is.”
Bottom line
For kids over 6 months with fever or pain, ibuprofen works faster and lasts longer. For kids 3-6 months, acetaminophen is the safer first choice. For babies under 3 months, call your doctor-don’t give medicine.
Always dose by weight. Always use the right tool. Never mix with other meds. And never assume because it’s over-the-counter, it’s risk-free.
Most parents want to do the right thing. The science is clear. Now you know how to use it right.
Write a comment